Changing my Bike Friday's drivetrain from MicroSHIFT R9 to Shimano Tiagra

On my review of my Bike Friday, I talked about the mediocre shifting. On of the possible fixes I mentioned was to replace the MicroSHIFT bar end shifters with Shimano shifters. The cost for the Shimano shifters is a bit over $100. But as I thought about this, I realized that the price of Shimano 10 speed bar end shifters is slightly more than the additional cost to replace all of the other parts needed to upgrade the drive train (Rear Derailleur, Chain, and Cassette) as well. So for about $200 - a bit less than twice the cost of replacing only the shifters, I can not only replace the bar end shifters, but the entire drive train, and move from MicroSHIFT 9 speed to Shimano Tiagra 10 speed. So what does all of this data that look like?



Component Part 9 Speed Price 10 Speed Price

Dura Ace SL-BS77 9-Speed Bar End Shifters $114.60
Dura Ace SL-BS79 10-Speed Bar End Shifters
$ 94.28
Tiagra RD-4700 GS Rear Derailleur
$ 38.64
Tiagra 4700 11-34 Cassette
$ 49.92
Tiagra CN-4601 10-speed Chain
$ 21.98
Shimano Tiagra 4700 10-Speed 34/50t 165mm Crankset
$100.07
English 68 width RS500
$ 19.99
Cost to replace only the current Bar End shifters (10 speed upgrade) $114.60 $203.90
Cost to replace all, including the Crankset / Cost to upgrade the Mondonico
$323.96
Added cost to upgrade new Bike Friday from 9 Speed to 10 Speed $ 89.30

So replacing the shifters will cost $114.60, while replacing the shifters AND the rest of the drivetrain parts (Derailleur, cassette, and chain) to upgrade from 9 speed to 10 speed will cost $203.90. That is only $89.30 more. In other words, replacing only the shifters, and staying with 9 speeds will cost more the over half of the total upgrade cost.

However, the replacement cost for cassettes and chains when doing maintenance, is quite a bit higher for 10 speed components than it is for 9 speed: ($49.00 + $21.89 vs. $10.48 + $9.23 or $70.89 total vs. $19.71 total. More than 3 times as much.

Note: The cost estimates listed above do not including the cost of replacing either the front derailleur or the crankset. This is because my internet research tells me that they should work fine with the other 10 speed parts listed.


Of course if I had the foresight to see this when I specified the bike in the first place, I might have been able to do this in the first place. The following table shows what it might have added to the price had I known then, what I know now.
I included an additional item at the bottom to include the cost of the R9 read Derailleur as well, since I had to do this after delivery before considering all of this.

Parts used on my bike as delivered Price half of cost
MicroSHIFT 9 Speed Bar End Shifter Set $77.15 $38.58
Sunrace 11-34 9 speed Cassette $20.95 $10.48
microSHIFT MarvoLT M46 Long Cage Rear Derailleur $12.00 $6.00
KMC X9.93 9-Speed Bike Chain $18.45 $9.23



Total Cost / Half cost, assumption of credit $128.55 $64.28
Cost of Tiagra parts $ 203.90
Presumed final cost: Cost of Tiagra parts less credit $139.63
Less cost of microSHIFT R9 read derailleur I wouln'd have needed ($20.00)
Presumed final cost: Cost of Tiagra parts less credit and R9 $119.63

I'm not sure what to do with this, but here it is...


Bottom Bracket Data

English 68 width-Bottom Bracket Shell I.D.: 1.37 RS-501 $19.99
English 68 width RS500 $16.30
English, 68 or 73 width MT 501 $20.99




9 SPEED



Cassete Cog
Chain Ring
11 13 15 17 19 21 24 28 34
53 93 79 68 60 54 49 43 37 30
39 68 58 50 44 40 36 31 27 22

% Chng sm to lg

11 🢥 13 13 🢥 15 15 🢥 17 17 🢥 19 19 🢥 21 21 🢥 24 24 🢥 28 28 🢥 34
   18%    15%    13%    12%    11%    14%    17%    21%












Speed in MPH
11 13 15 17 19 21 24 28 34
53 25 21 18 16 14 13 11 10 8
39 18 16 13 12 11 10 8 7 6

The ave step between cogs in % using the formula (range^(1/number of steps) = 15.15%
      Where range = big cog / small cog = 34/11 = 3.0909⋯
      And   Number of steps = number of gears - 1 = 9-1 = 8

Average Max Min Std Dev
Percent change when shifting to a Smaller cog 13.12% 17.65% 9.52% 2.64%
Percent change when shifting to a Larger cog 15.20% 21.43% 10.53% 3.54%




/
10 SPEED



Cassete Cog
Chain Ring
11 12 14 16 18 20 22 25 28 32
53 93 85 73 64 57 51 46 41 37 32
39 68 63 54 47 42 38 34 30 27 24












% Chng sm to lg

11 🢥 12 12 🢥 14 14 🢥 16 16 🢥 18 18 🢥 20 20 🢥 22 22 🢥 25 25 🢥 28 28 🢥 32
   9%    17%    14%    13%    11%    10%    14%    12%    14%












Speed MPH 53
25 23 20 17 15 14 12 11 10 9
39
18 17 14 13 11 10 9 8 7 6

The ave step between cogs in % using the formula (range^(1/number of steps) = 12.60%
Change = ((larger Cog - Smaller Cog) / Larger) Average Max Min Std Dev
Percent change when shifting to a Smaller cog 11.17% 14.29% 8.33% 1.87%
Percent change when shifting to a Larger cog 12.62% 16.67% 9.09% 2.37%

The most important factor here is the maximum % change, and where it happens. By my experience, it falls about where I am when riding on mostly flat ground, with a moderately fast group, which is exactly were I Don't want it to be. A large difference. So moving from 9 to 10 sp